197 The category of apostates ( Minim) also includes the following: This category includes even a person who is only an apostate in regard to a single commandment and transgresses only that one commandment as an act of rebellion; or even if he only does so to satisfy his lust; and similarly, one who casts off the yoke of Heaven, meaning that he denies the fundamental truth of HaShem’s existence and states that there is no God; and likewise, one who says that the Torah is indeed from Heaven, but “I cannot stand it,” meaning “I do not fulfill it;” or alternatively, one who says that the Torah is not from Heaven, even if he only is referring to a single verse, or a single grammatical aspect, such as missing letters or additional letters, or denies even one exegetical matter, such as a single Kal VaChomer or a single Gzeira Shava transmitted by our sages; Some also include those who deny the Oral Torah or matters that are established by the Sages; This category also includes one who says that the resurrection of the dead is not from the Torah, meaning that it is not hinted at in the Torah, even though he believes both in the Torah and the resurrection of the dead; Also, one who interprets Torah falsely, such as Menasheh, who would expound the Torah scornfully and falsely, saying things like “There was no reason for Moshe to write the verse, ‘And Lotan’s sister was Timna,’” and the like; Also, one who publicly violates the commandments of the Torah high-handedly, like Yehoyakim; One who abrogates the covenant of circumcision ( Brit Milah), meaning that as an act of rebellion, he does not circumcise himself, or alternately, he stretches his foreskin to look uncircumcised; One who himself sins and also causes others to sin such as Yeravam, which even includes transgressing minor prohibitions; Also, infidels ( Apikorsim), that is, those who treat a Torah scholar with contempt, to their faces; and also one who sits before his master and says, “this thing is forbidden,” or “this thing is permissible,” in the form of a statement, rather than in the form of a question; Also one who ridicules his master when he expounds something that seems to be an exaggeration, and he does not believe his words; Also one who treats Torah scholars with contempt, even not to their face, such as those who say “Those Rabbis…” in a degrading manner, or similarly, those who say, “With what have the Rabbis benefited us? They read the Torah for their own benefit, and study the Mishnah for their own benefit etc.,” or like those who say, “With what have the Rabbis benefited us? Never have they permitted a raven for us, nor have they prohibited a dove for us.” Also included is one who addresses his master by name, and does not respectfully address him as “my master and teacher;” Likewise, one who disgraces his fellow before a Torah scholar; and those who betray others to the Gentile authorities, whether they turned a Jew into the hands of the Gentile authorities to be beaten, or whether they only betrayed him monetarily to the Gentile authorities; Likewise, a communal leader who imposes excess fear upon the community out of pride, rather than for the sake of the Name of HaShem; One who disgraces the Festivals, in that he intentionally performs labor during Chol HaMo’ed as a show of disgrace and that he does not believe that it is forbidden, rather than for personal benefit; One who publicly embarrasses his fellow in his presence; One who derives honor from the shame of his friend, and it seems to me, that this too is if it is his presence; One who reads extraneous literature, such as the book of Ben Sira and the books of Ben La’anah, which are nonsensical books that draw a person’s heart and cause him to neglect his Torah study; The same applies to books of apostacy, such as those of the priests and ministers of the nations; However, books such as that written by Homer and other similar books, are considered to be mundane, and are as if he is merely reading a correspondence, as stated in the Jerusalem Talmud; One who whispers incantations over an injury, or even if he recites a verse over it and spits, irrespective of whether it is the verse, “I will not bring any of the diseases upon you,” or whether it has any other mention of illness, healing, or the Name of Heaven, but even if it is a verse such as, “ HaShem called to Moshe etc.”; One who pronounces the Name HaShem according to its letters outside the Temple, which the Jerusalem Talmud explains means that he does not mention Him by His title, in accordance to the verse, “This is My Name forever, and this is My remembrance from generation to generation.” However, in our Talmud we learn that this is specifically if he does so publicly; One who disgraces the word of HaShem, meaning that he recalls words of Torah in a filthy place; Likewise, one who reads the written Torah, but pays no heed to the words of the Mishnah, which explain the written Torah; Similarly, one who studies Torah but does not teach it, the exception being the secrets of the Torah, about which it states, “The lambs ( Kvasim - כבש ים) shall be for your clothing,” meaning, “Matters that are the secrets of the world ( Kivshono shel Olam - כבש ונו של עולם) should be hidden under your clothing.” It is only fitting to teach them to the pious ( Chassidim) of the generation, who are worthy of being taught; Similarly, one who is capable of engaging in Torah study but does not engage in it, and instead engages in business and other worldly matters; One who gossips ( Rechilut), meaning that he takes the words of one friend and brings them to another, and this applies even if they are not words that cause any shame or ill repute, and even if they are true, like what occurred with Doeg the Edomite and David; One who speaks evil speech ( Lashon Hara), in that he speaks of his fellow’s shamefulness, even if it is true; The slanderer ( Motzi Shem Ra) who relates false matters about his fellow to disgrace his name; Anyone who violates these three, that is, the gossiper, one who speaks evil speech and the slanderer, it is considered as if they have denied the primary foundation of HaShem ’s existence, and these are so severe that they are equal to the three cardinal sins of the Torah, these being idolatry, forbidden relations, and murder; One who lends to his fellow Jew with interest and did not return the interest to him will not rise upon the resurrection of the dead; One who transgresses the Shabbat is judged in purgatory ( Gehinom) for all generations; One who intentionally does not bear children and dies childless is excised from this world and will not have life in the coming world.